When it comes to a classic sub, you know one of the only places you can find one is at a small mom-and-pop sub shop. The type of place that feels like it's both locked in time, while simultaneously moving into the future.

I remember going to my first classic sub shop when I was a kid. I had to be 5 or so, and it was this little sub shop in Brick. I don't remember the name of the place, and unfortunately it no longer exists.

It was one of those tiny spots you'd get giant subs, and I still remember my favorite one from that place. A classic ham and cheese with lettuce, oil, and vinegar (back then I didn't put a lot of "stuff" on my sandwiches).

A simple memory, but one nonetheless. And it's unfortunate it's no longer around, but as they say, time moves on.

However, going back to my earlier comment, some places manage to move forward while still maintaining characteristics of the past. And if you live around Red Bank, you have one of those places that's been serving generations of families since 1959.

Mike Brant TSM
Mike Brant TSM

Elsie's Sub Shop

Elie's Sub Shop is one of those places that fits both the nostalgia of the past, but thrives even today. And once you walk into the shop, you'll understand why.

They've been in the same location throughout their history, which is pretty amazing. It's not a big place, but it doesn't have to be. One of the things that jumped out at me right away was all the amazing artwork on the walls.

Mike Brant TSM
Mike Brant TSM

Ready for the holidays

With the holiday season now here, Elsie's is the perfect place to let help feed your office, family, or whatever gathering you're hosting. Trust me, their food is amazing.

In fact, Elsie's was one of the contenders in the 2026 Jersey Shore Sandwich Playoffs. That's how good they are, and why they're absolutely worth a visit (check out the video below from the competition).

Thanksgiving Promotion

And if you haven't already done so (if it's not too late, that is), make sure you follow Elsie's Sub Shop on Instagram, post them to your story, and tag at least two friends.

Why? Because you'll have a chance to win a free sub meal as part of their Thanksgiving giveaway. The winner will be drawn on Nov. 19, so don't wait on this.

Mike Brant TSM
Mike Brant TSM

Most visited restaurants and food spots in Red Bank, NJ

These establishments logged the most visits in Red Bank last year.

The data — from May 2025 to May 2026 — comes from Townsquare partner Placer.Ai, which uses foot traffic, real estate and other location-based data for trend analysis.

Want to explore business trends in New Jersey? Submit a request to talk to a Townsquare New Jersey marketing specialist to discuss how to use this data.

Gallery Credit: Erin Vogt

First flakes: When does snow season start in NJ?

Gallery Credit: Dan Zarrow

The above post reflects the thoughts and observations of New Jersey 101.5 weekend host & content contributor Mike Brant. Any opinions expressed are his own.